Thursday, May 14, 2009

What do Users Want from Your Library Catalogue?

I've just been having my first look at the most recent OCLC report, Online Catalogs: What Users and Librarians Want. The results don't paint a very flattering picture of current generation catalogues but I don't think those findings are particularly surprising.

So what do users want? Here is a summary:
  • Direct links to online content - text and media formats
  • Evaluative content, such as summaries/abstracts, tables of contents and excerpts
  • Relevant search results
  • Item availability information - if the item is available and how to get it
  • Simple keyword search with an advanced, guided search option
You should read some of the detail in the report - it's really interesting. It certainly got me thinking. I believe that the results illustrate a couple of key points:
  1. Users want to start with a simple keyword search and get relevant results.
    Remember when Google just started up and the impact that their relevancy ranking had compared with search engines like Alta Vista and Yahoo! Now that's how everyone experiences the Internet and they want it in our catalogues.
  2. Catalogues are good when you know what you want.
    A bit of detail in the report suggests that catalogues are good when the user is looking for known items but really let people down when they are trying to discover information on a new topic. Random results from a keyword search aren't good enough. If you can't have the full text available online then people expressed a real need for more data to help them choose the good stuff. That included table of contents, summaries and excerpts as well as faceted searching to help them narrow down large result sets from keyword searches.
  3. If the whole thing isn't available right now online, 'how do I get it?' becomes the most important question.
    Assuming the user chooses a library catalogue as a discovery tool and manages to find some worthwhile resource their first preference is to link straight to the full text of the item online. If they can't have direct access there and then the detail around how and when can they get hold of the item becomes paramount.
What does this mean for the future of libraries and reference services? I see reference as the process of discovery based on identified information needs. However, the window (catalogue) to our biggest resource (our collection) doesn't appear to fulfill that need for discovery.

Does the library industry have enough dollars and/or expertise to develop catalogues that will meet our users expectations? Maybe libraries will not be in the discovery business for much longer? Should we be focussing on the delivery side of the equation? Could/should we outsource the discovery process to the institutions who are doing a better job of it (Google, Amazon, etc.) by making our collection data available to them in return for them sending traffic our way. Should reference services move to the Cloud to meet our users? Is it sustainable for individual libraries to all have their own uniques collections with an individual, self-contained discovery tool?

I see change coming and interesting times ahead.

Your thoughts? Leave a comment...

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Reference Excellence 2009 - welcome to the Ref-Ex wiki

The slides from my recent presentation at the Reference Seminar are also available on Slideshare (helpful, 'cause the accompanying notes are listed there as well).







Reference Excellence is an online training tool using a wiki as the delivery tool. The Ref-Ex project has been a long time coming (since 2004) but it's now finally up and running. Covering modules from introductory reference through to reference interview skills and legislation and policy the aim of Ref-Ex is to expand across all areas of reference and information services (readers advisory, local studies, and so on) providing core training for public library staff across NSW.
Take a look and start your own professional development today!

Reference Excellence

Monday, May 11, 2009

Beyond the Search Box

The slides from Paul Hagon's fascinating talk at the Reference at the Metcalfe Seminar are now available on Slideshare.net.
Paul is doing some really interesting things by mashing up data from the National Library with web services and APIs from sites like del.icio.us and Flickr to create enhanced services for users.
Visit Paul's blog for some more insight into what he's been up to...

RSS 4 Libraries

If anyone would like to catch up with my talk on how Libraries can use RSS feeds (without needing any technical skills) from the Reference at the Metcalfe Seminar last week I've just posted the slides on the RISG New Technologies blog.

You can also see them at Slideshare.net.

Friday, April 3, 2009

Libraries and Customer Privacy

We are in the early stages of the process of selecting a new ILS at MPOW and as a result I have been thinking about what I would like in an ILS. One of the directions that I personally would like to see us move is to retain more data about the way our members use our collection - borrower history, tags, reviews, etc. - with a view to improving the user experience of our online catalogue.

With that in mind this interesting post about privacy and service delivery caught my eye, Library Garden: What Libraries Can Learn from Facebook. There is a lively discussion in the comments. The issue of user privacy always seems to divide library workers. I definitely fall on the side of letting users decide what they want to keep private and opening up our systems and data to improve services. I've heard too many users asking me on service desks if we keep a record of what they have borrowed for me to think that many people are as concerned about their privacy as we are, as long as users must opt in.

Where do you stand?

Friday, March 27, 2009

Reference seminar 5 May

This year's reference@the Metcalfe will be on 5 May at the State Library of New South Wales. This is always a very popular seminar bringing together some great ideas which you can take back to your library.

You can see the full program and book here.

There will be a discussion of some dangerous ideas for reference and information services as well.

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

North Carolina digital collections collaboratory blog

A blog to add to your rss feeds is the North Caroline digital collections collaboratory blog.

The writers of this blog say that This blog was created for Digital Librarians in North Carolina to share experiences, exchange ideas, and develop collaborations. It was created by two such librarians after starting some “information-sharing” visits between our two institutions, and further meeting a few other NC-based folks at the recent LITA National Forum. We realized that many of us face the same challenges related to workflow, platforms, and institutional support, and it would be great if we could all benefit from potential solutions and approaches to issues.

There are some really interesting ideas being raised on this blog. Have a look at it and see what you think.